The results are in!

I expect to hear some flack for this, but the controversial issues all fall solidly under “some very misleading ones — be careful!” Please keep all flack to the tribe forums, as I’m going to be posting the challenge for public play and don’t want the arguments publicized. You will see that even though you may disagree with my call, once you hear my ineffable logic you will have no choice but to see that this decision is correct.

It was CLOSE. We ALMOST had to go to the tie-breaker. And if we did, the first tiebreker would have favored Two Girls One Tribe (with zero edited posts as compared to 3 in TribeGirl). The second tiebreaker would have been tough to call so I don’t want to go through it. The third tiebreaker would have gone to TribeGirl because in addition to their descriptions, they actually took the trouble to provide screenshots of the URLs and box off the correct portions, and you don’t get more descriptive than that!

With a final score of 13 (19 correct, 3 incorrect or duplicates) vs. 12 (20 correct, 4 incorrect or duplicates), the winning tribe is: Two Girls One Tribe!

TribeGirl, I’ll see you at tribal council at 3pm (or sooner).

As for the “little something special for the player on the winning tribe who gets the highest individual score”. That was spacekadt, with a total of SEVEN.

Great job all around, honestly. I wish I was able to keep this challenge to 24 hours as I originally hoped — many of the pieces weren’t found until well after that.