There was no rule against spamming before, however we clearly stated that we don’t approve of bots that impact the performance of the site.

MST had scripted 10 alts to spam every 30 seconds to get around the flood detection. You don’t do something like that without the thought “hey, maybe I am doing something wrong” crossing your mind.

We also didn’t have a rule that you couldn’t embed links that would delete every major klan, but we permabanned him for that the first time around.

As for people claiming that it’s our fault for setting emails to send by default: would it be our fault if he created a DDOS attack that raised our bandwidth bill through the roof? There’s no “rule” against that. But I’m pretty sure nobody would object if we banned a user for doing that.