Evil Trout Posted:

The idea is to eliminate some of the replies that are like “signed” or just a quote of something someone said.

That’s never going to happen, for reason put forth quite well above. Also because trolls will continue to do it just to be defiant. And everyone on the site’s a troll. So if that’s the sole goal, I vote don’t do it. If I get a vote.

Also, drama will be stirred by accusations of klan voting, people will downvote certain posts based just on who the poster is, etc. Have you learned nothing from domination and INCIT?

Evil Trout Posted:

It’s just for fun and to bump things.

Well, for fun, that’s cool. But to bump things? So all it would take to keep the recently active posts stay the same is to continue to upvote them? I’m not so sure that’s a good idea…