Orb Posted:

there’s no subjective way of determining whether a forum idea is good or bad.

Which is why all the “This idea sucks!” or “Crappy suggestions keep getting voted up!” comments mean nothing at all. Nothing. Because it’s all subjective. And just because you (not Orb, the generic “you”Log in to see images! think it sucks, doesn’t mean everyone else does. That’s why we vote.

Orb Posted:

So can anything be done? Perhaps. Maybe if sending in a forum idea required you to also send in 8 examples of material that would be appropriate to the forum build: 2 Enemies, 2 Thread Titles, 2 Typical Posts, and 2 Angry Replies. The extra work would deter people from make **** submissions, and the examples would help voters decide whether a forum idea would actually make for a fun build.

This sounds like a great idea.