I think all of the top 4 should get the peen, just with the other three having a semi-transparent 2, 3, or 4 superimposed over it indicating their finish. They all earned it considering how much effort they put in and how awesome the contest became. This could have been seriously lame, but everybody involved stepped up and delivered awesome.

Except for AAHZ, he’s a female dog upstanding member of society. Everybody else? Awesome.