The two most commonly proposed reasons for INCIT being **** are dump voting and the INCIT user base. You can’t necessarily fix the user base, but you can fix the issue of dump voting.

To do this I propose INCIT be divided into two divisions. Half of the INCIT users become part of division A and the other half part of division B. INCIT is played exactly the same was as it is now with one exception: division A votes on the submissions of division B and vice versa. This way there’s no incentive to dump vote— you can’t vote yourself out of a win.

The only problem with this is that it logically it would double the minimum required submissions to play.

[ Edited because it was pointed out that there is a minimum submission requirement currently in place. ]