I have a proposal.

Log in to see images!

So. Limit five characters per player per week. We all seem to agree on that.

Log in to see images!

Second, at the same time, before your week has started and before you’ve begun earning scoops at the beginning of a dom week, you could have each character select whether they wanted solo vanilla or klan vanilla; exactly the same kind of selection as for whether the char is playing or not. Just like enabled or disabled, solo vanilla or klan vanilla.

Log in to see images!

If klan vanilla is selected, char can join a klan raid twice in the upcoming dom week. However, their solo vanilla is nerfed to 2 scoops per 4 forums all week long. If solo vanilla is selected, no raids may be joined, and the character may not affect pwn count for any raids that happen. However, players who select Solo Vanilla get 8 scoops per 4 forums pwnt.

Log in to see images!

Now, when in a raid, every player selects one character to receive the klan vanilla. Only this character receives scoops while selected; the other characters joined to the raid get nothing. This can be changed during the raid, if the player wishes. So three people bring four chars each to a raid. Player A selects char 1 to receive vanilla. Player B selects char 5 to receive vanilla. Player C selects char 9. Now, each of those three characters receives klan vanilla. But none of the supporting characters receive vanilla, unless the selection is moved during the raid. So, if player A decides that char 1 has received enough, he can switch the receipt of vanilla to char 2. For a three person raid with four alts each, bumuming leeching from 3 chars, theoretical max scoops is 108 * 2 + 9 * 2 * 3 for the week = 272 theoretical scoops. You can add 24 to that to bumume one more alt from somewhere, making it 296. It’s also a fairly intuitive system, imo.

Log in to see images!

A solo player, at 8 scoops per 4 forums dommed = 9*8*3+8 = 224. bumume one rollover raid on sunday, potential solo vanilla is 248.

Thus, klan players can raid with their klan, and it will still give a significant (but not unbeatable) advantage. This is also bumuming a perfect collection rate, which simply doesn’t happen, and which is much easier for a solo dommer to pull off than a klan. What do people think?