The meat of this issue is this. It appears to the public that the moderators are not acting objectively and thus poisoning the community with favoritism towards some users and acting like they are on the witch hunt for others. As Crotch Zombie and Forumwarz by extension is a business, it does not serve the interests of the company to have such an image, however as it is a small business it is really up to those in charge to decide. Granted, a game centered around the activity of forum trolling draws a lot of trolls, however at some point there needs to be a line and this is why we have moderators.

I guess the point I am trying to make is that it is bad for business to have moderators that play favorites, the best course of action though would maintain business as usual and let one of them slip in such a way that it becomes blatantly obvious so that the only recourse can be to remove them.