MC Banhammer Posted:

Okay, wait.

In this thread, which had the same rules, I didn’t get the BP because the OP posted the first post.

In this thread we’re in now, the OP gave someone else the BP, even though the OP made the first post.

These contests must both follow the same rules. Some other mod/admin, please adjudicate?

One could say you didn’t get your BP for being a smartbum, but that’s beside the point. I’d go with Tub; “first post” contests go to the 1st reply, not OP.