I think that the point the OP is trying to make is that if everyone gathers scoops in exactly the same way and gets much the same amounts (depending on where you are in a streak) it would be about the same to just give everyone X scoops of whatever flavor every week and just card each other into wins or losses from there.

However with the way the flavors are set up (based on different requirements) they will of course remain essentially exclusive from each other, though I like the idea of making Antifreeze sort of an Anti-lemon as far as damage taken. Even if the scoops awarded are always 3 per run, you’d have to almost choose which flavor they are which would be the closest thing to strategy scoop gathering has next to refreshing the vanilla raid page.