Hate some of your ideas, but love critical hits.

Both ways. You at the forum and the forum at you.

You at the forum:When you post, the angry reploy is not insulting. It’s something like a lawsuit threat, committing suicide because of your post, congratulating your awesomeness, or something not a typical angry reply. That post provides the additional damage. May or may not depending on luck result in no damage hitting you on that turn.

The forum at you:Multiple people each post an insult, each of which damages you.