Well, the main flaw i see is that it requires active players to work effectively. Why not turn it into something a bit more like forumbuildr or itembuildr where the time window is longer, this would give more people a chance to play, upping the amount of quality (bumuming that you are more likely to get people playing is also bumuming you are more likely to get _good_ people playing)

Perhaps instead of a five submission cap it should be any more than 3 in a set hour window, or better yet, run multiple games during the course of a day.

One example would be to accept submissions on game 1 between 00:00 and 03:00, then accept submissions on game 2 and voting on game 1 between 03:00 and 06:00, and just continue with that trend. Allow non-submitters to vote too. This would solve a problem where early submissions are more likely to get more votes (somewhat of a problem with the other games).

It’s just an idea, it’s not really perfect, but I think it would help.