What you need to remember is that INCIT was NOT first introduced the way it is now.

The way it is now, it’s often not funny for several reasons, one of which is, imho, that it’s trolls feeding trolls. There’s not much creativity and cleverness there.

INCIT originally came with a picture AND A CLbum. You were supposed to label the picture as someone of that clbum (troll, camwhore, emo kid) would label it. This required creativity.

Unfortunately, as with all else on this site (including RP, see that other thread) became just troll-on-troll. Boring, and not funny.

Maybe INCIT would become re(?)-invigorated if that aspect were turned back on, and moderated (Phineas, are you listening) to make submitting something NOT in character bannable? Surely INCIT could stand theme days (a la Domination theme weeks) and see where it goes?