Balloon Posted:

Sounds like a good idea. But I’m not sure we could accurately test if they are being random, really discerning, or being a prick. What would we base them against? Other voters? Doesn’t help if they too are being random.

well, if you take both the % of the times they vote down on winning forums, and the % of times they vote up on losing forums, and then average these to be near 50%, that would be a good indication.