I’d still love to see this idea trialled, so how about making it another klan based theme?
For vanilla raids, instead of receiving a scoop for each forum you pwn that takes you up to 12, you receive a scoop for each forum you pwn that brings your total held forums higher by 1. So you’d get a scoop for forums held going up to 13, 14, 15 etc, but if it went down to 14 from 15, you wouldn’t get a scoop for bringing it back up again to 15, and only earn again when your total held forums moves up to 16.
This would play faster than a normal klan raid, dispensing with the whole denture chat rotating thing and waiting for forums to fall naturally, and I think be more fun and dynamic. Running such a raid when the servers are quiet would be desirable, but if two klans decided to choose the same time, chaos would ensue. Being able to speedrun forums would be a big advantage, and forward planning (who pwns what) would also be an advantage.
The amount of vanilla a single raid can bring in would be capped by the total number of forums, and how many visits you’re willing to burn to reach the absolute maximum. Anything over 52 forums held would involve a sacrifice of solo vanilla, since some alts would then have to hold more than 4 forums.
Actually this is a really interesting idea.