All of your ideas sound good, Evil Trout. Would the ForumBuildr score be something public or private? Regarding some of the other things people have brought up.

I’m anti-complex weighting system. It’s probably a lot more coding work than it’s worth. Also, I don’t want to have to do calculus to figure out my scores.

I actually like the plain up or down. It forces people to make a choice. Plenty of things can skate by on eh, ok. The forums we build should be as awesome as possible not just ok. If you’re just neutral about something then it’s not good enough.