if they have a few weeks of voting time, maybe 3, i dont know, then are dleted out, i disagree. makes room for fresh ideas

edit- some ideas just arent good enough i think..also i think you guys have made some of those toughest forums just too tough..keep hearing the nightmare stories of 200 smiles and stuff..like, jeez

Pickled male reproductive organbum Posted:

fresh ideas are not always good ideas

i already addressed that, though..sure there will be more crappy ones, but new ones that arent bad have a better chance too

-another edit: i dont really dabble in the forumbuildr much except to vote, but its still one of my opinions on how to improve it

those rise up pretty quickly, on their own, actually. even in the current system. a genuinely good idea submitted midweek can overtake most of the old crap floating around the top.

wilD-****22 Posted:

maybe most will be ****ty, but at least they will be NEW

oh i voted that one, if you mean my bad vote for that, i meant the alcoholics anonymous one, lemme reiterate

Snott Posted:

I’d be interested to see what might happen if forum ideas were given -10 instead of the usual -5. I’m sure a lot of stuff would still get murderfaced, but it might salvage a few decent ones that died untimely deaths.

Right now, I’m just amused that I get chocolate from things I submit that are purposefully bad. That’s awesome/kind of sad. Log in to see images!

lol..funny, but somewhat frightening i bet

AU is dead, its been -5’d – and the person who submitted it doesn’t really play anymore (it’d only stuck around because it had managed to do well every week, till now)

i guess that also means lulz56 won’t be getting a +2 to her buildrscore every week without trying, anymore.

Still lv10, no recent activity whatsoever. Someone copied it.

SG94 Posted:

Is it winning?

no

scullyangel Posted:

Uh, so is lulz back or did someone jack his idea for this week? The wording is almost identical.

Erm…

I’m really sorry to hear that this has been done before, but I’m the one who submitted this this week and I had absolutely no idea that it had been done before. I submitted it last week and it did quite well, so I didn’t think it would be a problem to submit it again this week.

Alcoholics Unanimous is the name of my old pub quiz team from university (I finished university in 2002) and the description is 100% my own work. If the wording is similar to an idea that’s been before then I find that rather surprising as it’s a complete coincidence.

I’ve only been part of the game for around 3 weeks, so I trust you’ll believe when I say that I had no way of seeing what the previous submitter had written!